IRAQ/CANADA: Jim Loney's reflection, "A tale of two fathers"


30 November 2005

IRAQ/CANADA: Jim Loney's reflection, "A tale of two fathers"

[Note: CPTer Jim Loney, currently being held captive in Iraq, wrote the
following reflection in 2004. A version of the story appeared in _Getting
in the Way: Stories From Christian Peacemaker Teams_ Herald Press, 2005 (See]

My father is 70 years old. I am 39.

I first told him in September [2003] that I was planning to go to Iraq with
a group called Christian Peacemaker Teams to do human rights work. He
said, "Well James, I'm not very excited about it," and then, "I wish you'd
think of your mother and I when you do these things."

We talked more about it when I went home to Sault Ste. Marie for a
Thanksgiving visit. We were on our way to the cottage to patch a leaky roof.
I told him I was scared, but that I felt it was something I needed to do. I
talked about how Rick Yuskiw--he was a year behind my brother Ed in grade
school--was sent to Afghanistan as part of Canada's war against terrorism,
and how one of his closest buddies was killed when a roadside bomb exploded
next to his jeep. If Rick was being asked to risk his life as a soldier then
I, as a pacifist Christian who believes that war is not the way to peace,
should be prepared to take the same risks.

My father's temper flared. "What can you accomplish by going there?" he
demanded. "It's futile. Every westerner is a target. They don't care who you
are or why you're there. It's just not worth it." Silence filled the truck.

The memory of a breezy June day when I was fourteen visited me. My father
had just purchased land on St. Joseph's Island and I was helping him to cut
a clearing in the trees for the house he would eventually build.

My father was bucking a log and I must have been standing too close. I don't
remember how it happened, but somehow the chainsaw in my father's hands
sliced through my sweatshirt and undershirt and left a foot-long scratch
across my chest that ran directly over my heart. I marvelled at the ragged
slash in my clothes, the red, pencil-thin cut. My Dad stepped back, sat down
shaking, his eyes wide with horror.

"Jesus Christ! Be careful," he said. I shrugged it off and suggested we go
back to work; at that age, I was still unfamiliar with the concept of
mortality. My father said he wanted to do something else.

Back in the present, I turned to look at my father sitting behind the wheel.
I knew there was nothing I could tell him that would make him feel any
better about my decision. We somehow found our way into another

I called my parents on New Year's Eve to say goodbye. My father launched
into a defence of American foreign policy, asked me why I was always
criticizing the Americans. I took a deep breath, bit my tongue.


Khadan's father is called Ismael. Ismael is 60 years old. Khadan is 22. He
earns three dollars a day as a street cleaner for the municipality of

I interviewed Ismael at Baghdad's Abu Hanifa Shrine where he sings the call
to prayer five times a day. The corneas of his eyes were a smoky white
colour and noticeably without pupils. Ismael was blind.

He explained that his son and a friend were swimming in the Tigris River on
October 19, 2003 when they heard an explosion--an everyday occurrence in
Baghdad. It was only when they heard gunfire close by that they became
scared and got out of the water. They were both shot by American
soldiers--Khadan in the right foot--and then swept up into the U.S. Army's
massive security detainee system.

According to Ismael, the Americans charged him with being in possession of a
rocket propelled grenade. "This is impossible," he said. "My son was excused
from the army because of a head injury he received in 1997. He does not
know how to use these weapons. He is innocent."

Fifteen days later, Ismael learned that his son was being held in a nearby
hospital but he was not allowed to visit. Khadhan was transferred to Abu
Ghraib Prison in November and, after repeated requests, "they had pity on my
situation" and allowed him to visit his son at the end of December.

"My son said the food is sometimes good and sometimes not. Sometimes they
get diarrhea. The guards don't allow the detainees to receive clothes from
visitors." During his second visit, Ismael wore a track suit under his
tunic and successfully smuggled it to Khadhan.

At the end of the interview, Ismael let go of his cane and extended his arms
towards me with his palms facing upwards. "I just want my son back," he
said, eyes staring lifelessly in an open, pleading face. "Can you help to
get my son released?"

Several days later my family called. My father's voice was tentative,
nervous. "How are you, James? Are you okay?" I told him that I was fine,
feeling much better after spending the day in bed with a fever two days
before. "Oh--are you sure you're okay?" Yes, I'm really fine. "What kind of
food do you have to eat?" I told him. "Well, make sure you get enough to
eat." Okay. "You be careful now," he said.

When the call was done, I closed my eyes and saw my father, his arms
reaching helplessly across an ocean and pleading for the return of his son.
I saw Ismael and Patrick, searching blindly for their sons, united--if in no
other way--by their vulnerability. First grief, and then strength poured out
of my heart into my arms. I had work to do.