IRAQ REFLECTION: From Here to Where?



January 2012

REFLECTION: From Here to Where?

 by Bud

is late afternoon. The sun has disappeared. It is fairly cold. We are seated on
benches in front of a home in the Makhmoud refugee camp in northern Iraq,
speaking with Josef and Armeena. About two years ago, they were part of a
delegation of about forty-six persons who formed a Peace Brigade. They had
intended to meet with Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan and deliver a letter to
him simply explaining that this group, and the Kurdish people, were not
terrorists. They wanted peace. They wanted what all of us want (and many of us
expect) — our basic human rights. Mr. Erdogan refused to meet with them.
Instead, the group was arrested, tried and sentenced to ten to fifteen years in
prison. Josef and Armeena fled. Ten of the group remain in prison today.

hours later, three of us CPTers are seated with two vice-consuls in the offices
of the Turkish Consulate. We have brought with us a tin of cookies and a letter
explaining our hope that this New Year could, indeed, be the year where people
tried to find alternatives to violence and that we will look back and say 2012
was the year of change.

“I realize
that violence does not work,” vice-consul Cafer Agik told us, “but the PKK [Kurdistan
Workers’ Party] are terrorists and when they attack us, we have to fight back.”

At the refugee
camp, we had informed each group we spoke with that we would have a meeting at
the Turkish Consulate the following morning, and asked what they would like us
to say on their behalf. Repeatedly, the message echoed Armeena’s words to the Turkish
judge when she was tried for her participation in the Peace Brigade. “You have
sent my children to the mountains. I have three martyrs, my children, killed by
the government.” And another Josef stated, “Here in the camp are children,
women and old people. Erdogan sees us as terrorists. I do not want to kill
police, but I want our right to live together.”

A span of
twenty hours. A refugee camp tucked away off the back-roads outside the city of
Hawler, and a modern office in the city in a recently constructed office
building offering spacious views of the region from every window. All the
parties we spoke with expressed the realization that violence does not work.
Yet each side lives seemingly far removed from the realities of the other.

In the
Consulate, we had talked of education, constitutional change, and seeing one
another as human beings. I was truly grateful for the opportunity to meet with
the refugees in the camp and the vice-consuls at the Consulate who took
considerable time to dialogue with us. But upon leaving, I continued to wonder
what it will take for both sides to sit down, to look one another in the eyes
and share their common humanity. Only then can this year be the year when
people take real risks to enact change.


Read More Stories

Dozens of people crowd toward the entrance of a checkpoint, waiting for Israeli military to open the gate.

Privilege of movement

Basic freedom of movement in Palestine—walking to the grocery store, driving to visit family, or flying internationally—depends on your nationality, race, and religion. As a Palestinian, you are denied these rights as others in your country move freely.

A person wearing a red CPT vest walks along a road with the apartheid wall to their right, covered in graffiti and towering over them.

Dear White Supremacist

CPT Palestine team members engaged in a friendly and introductory conversation with a white person, but it took an unexpected turn.

a graphic image with large bold text reading FREE MORIA 6

After the 2020 fire in Moria

Six young migrants are made scapegoats of a failed EU migration policy – Call for fair and transparent trial for the Moria 6 on 6 March 2023 in Lesvos! 

Skip to content